22 Apr 2025
Books

apple books replacement superior ui/ux, grand reader app that ...

...satisfies customer needs

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Freemium

People love using similar products but resist paying. You’ll need to either find who will pay or create additional value that’s worth paying for.

Should You Build It?

Build but think about differentiation and monetization.


Your are here

You're entering a space with a good number of competitors (n_matches = 13), so there's demonstrated interest in enhanced reading experiences. Given the "Freemium" category, users appreciate these reading apps but often resist paying for them. Since there is no use or buy signals, it's difficult to tell what people think about this idea. To succeed, you'll need to find a specific user segment willing to pay for a superior reading experience or offer additional premium value. Think about what 'grand' means to readers and how your app can uniquely satisfy those needs beyond basic functionality. Differentiation and a clear monetization strategy will be crucial to thriving in this competitive landscape.

Recommendations

  1. First, deeply understand what frustrates users with existing reading apps like Apple Books. Is it the interface, lack of features, or something else? Use this insight to design a UI/UX that truly solves these pain points and offers a demonstrably better experience. Look into the ReadHero launch and the suggestions that users are looking for.
  2. Identify the specific user segments that would value a "grand reader app". Are they students, researchers, book reviewers, or casual readers? Understanding their needs will help you tailor features and marketing efforts effectively. Many users of ReadHero want note exporting from their app. Is this a key feature to implement?
  3. Since users resist paying in this category, explore potential premium features that would entice them to upgrade. Could it be advanced annotation tools, personalized recommendations, cloud syncing, or exclusive content? Consider features like bulk note revision tools, which were requested by ReadHero users.
  4. Consider a tiered pricing model where the basic app is free, but more advanced features or storage require a subscription. You could also explore a one-time purchase option for specific features. ReadToMe was criticized for its high cost, so price-sensitive users should be a focus.
  5. Explore potential partnerships with authors, publishers, or educational institutions to offer exclusive content or features within your app. This could add significant value and attract a wider user base. A virtual bookshelf app successfully implemented AI book recommendations and Hyra implemented a futuristic sci-fi experience using AI.
  6. Given the concerns around text-to-speech quality and cost in similar products, focus on integrating high-quality, natural-sounding TTS options and clearly communicate the value proposition for any associated costs. Consider allowing users to turn paper books into audio.
  7. Before a full launch, conduct user testing with a representative sample of your target audience to gather feedback on the UI/UX, features, and pricing. This will help you iterate and refine your app based on real-world usage. Pay attention to the feedback that ReadToMe received, as many users were turned off due to a clunky UI.
  8. Develop a comprehensive content strategy that includes blog posts, tutorials, and social media updates showcasing the unique features and benefits of your app. Highlight how it solves specific user problems and enhances their reading experience.
  9. Consider offering a free trial period or a limited version of the app to allow users to experience its value before committing to a purchase. This can help overcome initial resistance to paying for a reading app.

Questions

  1. What specific UI/UX paradigms can you borrow and extend from outside the ebook reader app space to create a genuinely 'grand' experience that sets you apart from the incumbents?
  2. Given the 'Freemium' category dynamics, what are the 2-3 'must-have' features that will drive the highest conversion rate from free to paid users, and how will you measure their impact?
  3. Considering the competitive landscape and user resistance to paying, how will you strategically leverage network effects or community features to create a sustainable competitive advantage and increase user engagement?

Your are here

You're entering a space with a good number of competitors (n_matches = 13), so there's demonstrated interest in enhanced reading experiences. Given the "Freemium" category, users appreciate these reading apps but often resist paying for them. Since there is no use or buy signals, it's difficult to tell what people think about this idea. To succeed, you'll need to find a specific user segment willing to pay for a superior reading experience or offer additional premium value. Think about what 'grand' means to readers and how your app can uniquely satisfy those needs beyond basic functionality. Differentiation and a clear monetization strategy will be crucial to thriving in this competitive landscape.

Recommendations

  1. First, deeply understand what frustrates users with existing reading apps like Apple Books. Is it the interface, lack of features, or something else? Use this insight to design a UI/UX that truly solves these pain points and offers a demonstrably better experience. Look into the ReadHero launch and the suggestions that users are looking for.
  2. Identify the specific user segments that would value a "grand reader app". Are they students, researchers, book reviewers, or casual readers? Understanding their needs will help you tailor features and marketing efforts effectively. Many users of ReadHero want note exporting from their app. Is this a key feature to implement?
  3. Since users resist paying in this category, explore potential premium features that would entice them to upgrade. Could it be advanced annotation tools, personalized recommendations, cloud syncing, or exclusive content? Consider features like bulk note revision tools, which were requested by ReadHero users.
  4. Consider a tiered pricing model where the basic app is free, but more advanced features or storage require a subscription. You could also explore a one-time purchase option for specific features. ReadToMe was criticized for its high cost, so price-sensitive users should be a focus.
  5. Explore potential partnerships with authors, publishers, or educational institutions to offer exclusive content or features within your app. This could add significant value and attract a wider user base. A virtual bookshelf app successfully implemented AI book recommendations and Hyra implemented a futuristic sci-fi experience using AI.
  6. Given the concerns around text-to-speech quality and cost in similar products, focus on integrating high-quality, natural-sounding TTS options and clearly communicate the value proposition for any associated costs. Consider allowing users to turn paper books into audio.
  7. Before a full launch, conduct user testing with a representative sample of your target audience to gather feedback on the UI/UX, features, and pricing. This will help you iterate and refine your app based on real-world usage. Pay attention to the feedback that ReadToMe received, as many users were turned off due to a clunky UI.
  8. Develop a comprehensive content strategy that includes blog posts, tutorials, and social media updates showcasing the unique features and benefits of your app. Highlight how it solves specific user problems and enhances their reading experience.
  9. Consider offering a free trial period or a limited version of the app to allow users to experience its value before committing to a purchase. This can help overcome initial resistance to paying for a reading app.

Questions

  1. What specific UI/UX paradigms can you borrow and extend from outside the ebook reader app space to create a genuinely 'grand' experience that sets you apart from the incumbents?
  2. Given the 'Freemium' category dynamics, what are the 2-3 'must-have' features that will drive the highest conversion rate from free to paid users, and how will you measure their impact?
  3. Considering the competitive landscape and user resistance to paying, how will you strategically leverage network effects or community features to create a sustainable competitive advantage and increase user engagement?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 13
  • Engagement: Medium
    • Average number of comments: 5
  • Net use signal: 9.2%
    • Positive use signal: 13.5%
    • Negative use signal: 4.3%
  • Net buy signal: -3.1%
    • Positive buy signal: 2.3%
    • Negative buy signal: 5.4%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

ReadHero - The All in One Reading App

04 Nov 2024 Books Productivity Apple

Readhero is an iOS app for tracking books and jotting down notes —combining the best of Goodreads, Readwise, and Bookly. With AI text recognition, easily scan books, capture and edit notes, organize in groups, and stay motivated with streak tracking.

ReadHero's Product Hunt launch garnered positive feedback, with users congratulating the team and highlighting its potential for avid readers as a personal book coach. Key requests include note exporting, Android/Web app versions, importing books/notes from various sources like Kindle and Goodreads, and bulk note revision features. The streak feature was commended as a motivator. Some users also inquired about the development framework used. A minor issue regarding typos on the webpage was pointed out.

Users criticized the product launch for lacking a book recommendation feature based on logged books and noted the presence of typos on the webpage, which could negatively impact user perception and credibility.


Avatar
146
13
23.1%
13
146
23.1%
Relevance

I created an app to listen to my books while I work

03 Apr 2023 Productivity

I like to gain knowledge but I hate reading and I don’t have much time to watch youtube videos. Podcasts is an option but they have more ads than information. So what can I do? I listen to books.If I have a physical hard copy of the book or a PDF/EPUB soft copy I don’t have any problem I just use my app to convert them into audiobooks and use voices that sound like narrators from movies and listen to them while travelling or coding or cooking it doesn’t matter what I am doing I just listen to my favourite books.My app not only converts pdf and ebooks into audiobooks it can also convert images to audiobooks. So every night I just scan a few chapters from my physical books through this app and the next day I listen to them while working.Imagine you complete your books or reading quota by listening to them. A major boost in my productivity.You can check it out on Google play

Uses app to convert books to audiobooks for productivity.

Podcasts have more ads than information.


Avatar
2
1
100.0%
100.0%
1
2
100.0%
100.0%
Relevance

The App for Daily Readers. Track, Finish, and Enjoy Your Books

08 Aug 2024 Books

Hey there,I am building an app to help people incorporate books into their daily routine on Android and IOS. The goal is to let users track their reading, their books, win prizes and ultimately reinforce their reading habit.Can you give me some feedback about the features necessary for such an app?Thank you :)


Avatar
1
1
Relevance

Hyra - Immersive AI reading app for Apple Vision Pro

Experience the next frontier in reading: the first-ever app designed for Apple Vision Pro that creates fully immersive scenes based on the book you’re reading, powered by AI.

Hyra's launch on Product Hunt generated considerable excitement, particularly regarding its immersive and personalized reading experience on Apple Vision Pro. Many users expressed enthusiasm for experiencing futuristic sci-fi settings and AI-generated scenes. Several users highlighted the potential of the technology, with some calling it groundbreaking and the future of reading. Suggestions included features for dyslexic readers, scene change markers, and seamless integration with Apple Vision. Questions were raised about device compatibility, cost, AI tech, the frequency of backdrop changes, and studies on potential distractions.

Users express concerns about the high cost and limited device compatibility, particularly for dyslexic readers. Several potential customers are unable to test the feature due to not owning the product or its unavailability. One user questions whether the backdrops are distracting. Finally, a user wants to see how it performs with Apple's AVP before committing to purchase.


Avatar
187
15
33.3%
6.7%
15
187
33.3%
6.7%
Relevance

Opus Audiobooks - Get well-read with must-reads

22 May 2024 Books Audio Apple

Opus Audiobooks offers a simple and affordable gateway to classic literature on iOS. The app offers an expertly curated selection of classics, read by humans. The visual design captures the timeless elegance of well-crafted books to inspire every interaction.


Avatar
5
5
Relevance

Book highlights - Manage book and kindle quotes

22 Jul 2024 iOS Books Tech

Book Highlights is an app designed for readers who want to efficiently manage their books and reading notes. - Kindle integration: Import books and highlights from Kindle devices using "My Clippings.txt" - iCloud sync - Add highlights manually or using camera


Avatar
6
6
Relevance

ReadToMe (iOS) turns paper books into audio

05 Feb 2024 iOS Books Productivity

I'm launching something that started as a side project publicly today: ReadToMe, which is an iPhone app that turns paper books and other printed text into audio.Originally this was a Christmas present for my fiancée, who loves books but has an eye problem that makes it hard for her to read more than a few pages at a time. She mostly listens to audiobooks while following along with the paper book, but some books aren't available in audiobook or even e-book form, and all of the existing apps we tried were surprisingly bad at scanning paper books into audio — they make lots of mistakes, include footnotes and page numbers, etc., in a way that really degrades the experience.Being an AI-oriented engineer by training, I had a crack at solving the problem myself, and was pleasantly surprised at how well the proof of concept worked. I then had some time free while shutting down my previous company (Mezli, YC W21), during which I polished up the app to the point you see it at now.The way it works:On the front end, it's a SwiftUI app (mostly written by ChatGPT!) that consists mostly of a document scanner (VNDocumentCameraViewController) and a custom-built audio player.The back end is more complex — book photos are first sent to an OCR API, then some custom code I wrote does a first pass at stitching together and correcting the results. Then, the corrected OCR results are sent to GPT-3.5-turbo for further post-processing and re-stitching together, and finally to a text-to-speech API for conversion to audio.The hardest part of this process was actually getting the GPT calls right — I ended up writing a custom LLM eval framework for making sure the LLM wasn't making edits relative to the true text of the book.A few issues remain, which I'll work on fixing if the app gets a significant amount of traction, including:1) It can take multiple minutes to get audio back from a scan, especially if it's on the longer side (10+ pages). I'll be able to bring this down by spinning up dedicated servers for the OCR and TTS back-end.2) The LLM sometimes does TOO good of a job at correcting "mistakes" in book text. This issue crops up particularly often when an author deliberately uses improper grammar, e.g. in dialogue.The app is priced at $9.99/month for up to 250 pages/month right now, which I estimate will just about cover the costs of API calls. I'll be bringing the price point down as the pricing of the required AI APIs comes down. There's also a 3-day free trial if you want to try it out.If you do find this useful, or know somebody who might, I'd appreciate you giving it a try or letting them know! And please let me know if you have any feedback, including issues or feature requests.

Users expressed concerns about the $9.99 price point, considering it too high, especially for the limited page access offered. There's interest in high-quality text-to-speech (TTS) for various formats, with some users suggesting alternatives like Narakeet or native iOS solutions, while others criticize the robotic sound of native TTS. Questions about onboard text recognition, speech synthesis APIs, and potential copyright issues were raised. Positive feedback includes excitement for the product, its features, and suggestions for marketing strategies. Users are also looking forward to a demo and further development updates.

Users criticized the product for its limited use case, particularly for audiobooks, and its high cost relative to the perceived value. The 250-page monthly limit was seen as too restrictive, and there were concerns about price and competition. The quality of text-to-speech (TTS) was deemed poor, with native TTS sounding robotic and the setup being complex. Users were disappointed with the non-integration of native iOS TTS and the lack of consideration for alternatives like ElevenLabs. Legal issues regarding copyright and sharing, as well as the lack of language and translation options, were also points of contention.


Avatar
74
35
-2.9%
-14.3%
35
74
8.6%
Relevance

I built an app to never forget the books I read

18 Jun 2024 Books Productivity

Hello HN,I'm a 21 year old CS student from Hamburg, Germany.I enjoy reading books but a lot of the time I forget the key ideas. To solve this problem I created an app that sends me 5 phrases and qoutes via email.Let me know what you think. It's free.-----------------------------------------Also on Product Hunt: https://www.producthunt.com/posts/remind5Twitter: https://x.com/soheil_jsLinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/in/soheiln/


Avatar
4
4
Relevance

A unique way to discover books, TV shows, video games, and more

10 Sep 2024 Books

I created this little web app after finding it hard to books I actually enjoyed reading.The apps makes it super easy for you to describe what you're looking for, then gives you recommendations that match your description.It currently works for books (fiction and non-fiction), TV shows, movies, video games, and songs.I've found that a little bit of exploration goes a long way... and I've personally found some great stuff.Please let me know what you think!


Avatar
1
1
Top
OSZAR »