11 May 2025
Productivity

Melofi is a productivity web app that offers Lofi music alongside ...

...features like notes, a calendar widget, an alarm, a calculator, and stats tracking. Users can select animated backgrounds to enhance their experience and connect their Spotify for personalized playlists. The platform aims to support students and remote workers by providing a cozy and affordable productivity environment. But i want a desktop app with multi improved feature

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Freemium

People love using similar products but resist paying. You’ll need to either find who will pay or create additional value that’s worth paying for.

Should You Build It?

Build but think about differentiation and monetization.


Your are here

You're entering a market with a decent number of competitors (n_matches is 12), all vying to provide that perfect blend of focus and relaxation. The good news is that similar products have high engagement. The bad news is that you are in the 'Freemium' category, where people love using similar products but resist paying. Since similar products have high engagement, this is good news, but you will need to find who will pay or create additional value that’s worth paying for.

Recommendations

  1. Given the criticisms of similar products, prioritize a seamless user experience. Address concerns about RAM usage and performance by optimizing your desktop application. A sluggish app will drive users away, especially when the core value proposition is productivity. Learn from FocusFusion, which received overwhelmingly positive feedback for its design and productivity focus.
  2. Focus on providing a unique and compelling value proposition beyond just Lofi music and basic productivity tools. The similar product 'I made an all-in-one desktop app...' faced criticism for lacking novelty and a clear value proposition. Consider what specific problems your app solves better than existing solutions. For example, can you create a more seamless or more personalized experience for users?
  3. Thoroughly test your application on different operating systems, especially Linux, since several similar products have received requests for Linux support. Also, ensure integration with existing platforms works flawlessly. Google Calendar integration was a key missing feature in other similar products. This will make your product more attractive to a broader audience.
  4. Consider alternatives to a subscription model, or at least offer a compelling free tier. 'I made an all-in-one desktop app...' faced resistance due to its subscription pricing. Explore options like one-time purchases or team-based pricing as alternatives. Also consider offering personalized help or consulting as ways to generate revenue.
  5. Prioritize features that enhance focus and minimize distractions. Users of similar products appreciate clean interfaces, cool animations, and dark mode options. Ensure your Pomodoro timer and other features work flawlessly without disrupting the music or user experience, as this was a point of concern for Lofi.life and Melofi users.
  6. Identify which users get the most value from free versions by closely analyzing user behavior and feedback. Focus on understanding their needs and pain points. If students or remote workers derive significant benefits from the free version, tailor premium features that address their specific requirements.
  7. Create premium features that help them even more such as advanced customization options, exclusive soundscapes, or enhanced collaboration tools. These premium offerings should provide substantial value that justifies the cost. Consider offering personalized recommendations based on user data to make it even more effective.
  8. Test different pricing approaches with small groups, before launching it to your general audience. Gather insights from users. It is imperative to understand their willingness to pay for specific features. Iterate based on the feedback to find a pricing model that maximizes revenue while remaining competitive.
  9. Differentiate your app through unique features like AI-powered music recommendations or advanced analytics to track productivity patterns. As chillify.me demonstrated, AI-crafted content can be a unique selling point. Integrate user feedback to continuously enhance the app's offerings and meet evolving user needs.

Questions

  1. Given the freemium nature of the market, what specific premium features will provide enough value to convert free users into paying customers, and how will you market these features effectively?
  2. How can you ensure your desktop application maintains high performance and avoids excessive RAM usage, especially considering the criticisms faced by similar products?
  3. Considering the feedback on similar products, how will you create a unique and differentiated user experience that addresses user needs more effectively than existing solutions?

Your are here

You're entering a market with a decent number of competitors (n_matches is 12), all vying to provide that perfect blend of focus and relaxation. The good news is that similar products have high engagement. The bad news is that you are in the 'Freemium' category, where people love using similar products but resist paying. Since similar products have high engagement, this is good news, but you will need to find who will pay or create additional value that’s worth paying for.

Recommendations

  1. Given the criticisms of similar products, prioritize a seamless user experience. Address concerns about RAM usage and performance by optimizing your desktop application. A sluggish app will drive users away, especially when the core value proposition is productivity. Learn from FocusFusion, which received overwhelmingly positive feedback for its design and productivity focus.
  2. Focus on providing a unique and compelling value proposition beyond just Lofi music and basic productivity tools. The similar product 'I made an all-in-one desktop app...' faced criticism for lacking novelty and a clear value proposition. Consider what specific problems your app solves better than existing solutions. For example, can you create a more seamless or more personalized experience for users?
  3. Thoroughly test your application on different operating systems, especially Linux, since several similar products have received requests for Linux support. Also, ensure integration with existing platforms works flawlessly. Google Calendar integration was a key missing feature in other similar products. This will make your product more attractive to a broader audience.
  4. Consider alternatives to a subscription model, or at least offer a compelling free tier. 'I made an all-in-one desktop app...' faced resistance due to its subscription pricing. Explore options like one-time purchases or team-based pricing as alternatives. Also consider offering personalized help or consulting as ways to generate revenue.
  5. Prioritize features that enhance focus and minimize distractions. Users of similar products appreciate clean interfaces, cool animations, and dark mode options. Ensure your Pomodoro timer and other features work flawlessly without disrupting the music or user experience, as this was a point of concern for Lofi.life and Melofi users.
  6. Identify which users get the most value from free versions by closely analyzing user behavior and feedback. Focus on understanding their needs and pain points. If students or remote workers derive significant benefits from the free version, tailor premium features that address their specific requirements.
  7. Create premium features that help them even more such as advanced customization options, exclusive soundscapes, or enhanced collaboration tools. These premium offerings should provide substantial value that justifies the cost. Consider offering personalized recommendations based on user data to make it even more effective.
  8. Test different pricing approaches with small groups, before launching it to your general audience. Gather insights from users. It is imperative to understand their willingness to pay for specific features. Iterate based on the feedback to find a pricing model that maximizes revenue while remaining competitive.
  9. Differentiate your app through unique features like AI-powered music recommendations or advanced analytics to track productivity patterns. As chillify.me demonstrated, AI-crafted content can be a unique selling point. Integrate user feedback to continuously enhance the app's offerings and meet evolving user needs.

Questions

  1. Given the freemium nature of the market, what specific premium features will provide enough value to convert free users into paying customers, and how will you market these features effectively?
  2. How can you ensure your desktop application maintains high performance and avoids excessive RAM usage, especially considering the criticisms faced by similar products?
  3. Considering the feedback on similar products, how will you create a unique and differentiated user experience that addresses user needs more effectively than existing solutions?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 12
  • Engagement: High
    • Average number of comments: 22
  • Net use signal: 10.2%
    • Positive use signal: 17.8%
    • Negative use signal: 7.6%
  • Net buy signal: -3.3%
    • Positive buy signal: 0.7%
    • Negative buy signal: 4.0%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

I made an all-in-one desktop app with a no-BS approach to get work done

Hi HN! This is Daniel from Floutwork (https://www.floutwork.com)Floutwork is an all-in-one desktop app designed to serve as a personal work system, offering a no-BS approach to getting real work done online.Background: When I transitioned from a development role to a product management role, I realized there was no real organization or structure to the way I worked as a PM. Tasks I needed to complete were scattered across emails, Teams, meetings, etc. I was inundated with emails and found myself juggling multiple browser windows, numerous open tabs, and other desktop applications. This overwhelming situation made it clear that success in my new role hinged on being self-organized and focused. After reading the book "Deep Work" by Cal Newport, I recognized that my work habits were counterproductive to accomplishing meaningful work. After that, I delved further into the "focus and productivity" path, read more books on the subject, and decided to integrate these concepts and methodologies into a single app. I could have created a specialized tool that addressed only one or two problems, like many other apps out there, but I knew that building a single app designed to assist with the workflow from start to finish was the only way to eliminate as many distractions and friction points as possible. Honestly, I could've wrapped up development way sooner if I'd just tackled one issue. But what's the point if one part of my workflow rocks and the rest sucks?What's the problem with modern work? You might be using a combination of a task manager and a calendar to track tasks. To work on a task, though, you probably bounce to your browser full of tabs. If you use desktop apps like Teams, Slack, or Discord, this bouncing back and forth becomes even worse because every link you click on opens in the browser. The real problem is when we jump to a browser full of tabs every time, we get distracted by all the tabs and get sidetracked, or our old habits kick in due to how our brains are now wired, and we start aimlessly browsing. This causes a lot of friction in our flow. This is one of the main reasons why people today are not able to focus or don't feel motivated to get work done. What usually takes 1 hour to complete can take up to 3 hours.What's unique about Floutwork? Floutwork has an excellent task management system and a calendar view right next to it to intelligently show you when you can work on your tasks amidst your busy schedule. However, it goes beyond that and lets you pin your work apps right within Floutwork. Once you know you need to work on a task, you can quickly hop on to your web apps right within Floutwork and get that done, and then repeat. Every time you access a web app within Floutwork, any tabs you open within that app stay within that app, so you only get to see the tabs to get your current task done. This powerful flow cuts down all the distractions and friction points that come between tasks and work getting done.Now that all your work can be consolidated into one unified system, you can access powerful tools in a distraction-free way to:- Monitor your work habits- Gamify your tasks- Experience an immersive focus mode for tasks- Open a command bar without losing your flow to open apps, links, tools, add tasks, ask ChatGPT, etc.- Quickly take work notes in context- Clean out your emails with a few clicks- Access AI tools via ChatGPT meaningfully right within your flowThis app is designed for people in roles like PMs, freelancers, managers, admins, and marketers, where being self-organized online is crucial for success. I know the HN community has a lot of developers. While this app can offer some benefits to devs, it won't be a game-changer for your workflow, especially if you're primarily in VS Code or other desktop development tools most of the day.I'd love to invite you all to try out the product and would appreciate hearing your feedback!

Users are intrigued by the Show HN product's concept of organizing workflow with features like per-app tabs and task-based organization, comparing it to existing solutions like Emacs, Obsidian, and Logseq. Concerns include Linux support, integration with existing platforms, and the subscription pricing model. The app's requirement for an account and admin permissions, as well as a broken website link, were criticized. Some users are excited about the potential for improved productivity, while others prefer a modular approach or are skeptical about the app's distinctiveness. The name 'flout work' sparked discussion, and there's interest in a Linux version and a trial without credit card requirements.

The product faces criticism for requiring too much initial buy-in and being unsuitable for programming, with a complex and unclear value proposition. Users find the workspace and tab management overdone and lacking novelty, with no Linux support and sluggish performance. The need for an account, admin permissions, and a subscription fee are also concerns. The app is compared unfavorably to existing tools like Emacs, and its Electron base is criticized for resource usage. Privacy policy errors and a confusing name add to the negative feedback. Users suggest it lacks distinct features and collaborative capabilities, and question the desktop app choice over web alternatives.


Avatar
206
104
-4.8%
-8.7%
104
206
14.4%
1.9%
Relevance

Melofi - Chill. Focus. Create.

Melofi: Your ultimate web app for a chill and focused environment. Handpicked Lofi tracks, mesmerizing visuals, and productivity tools. Elevate your vibe.

Users generally provided positive feedback, highlighting the app's soothing effects and useful features like the to-do list, timer, and reminders. One user noted the need for a headset, while another mentioned an issue with calendar connection. A specific issue was raised regarding small pauses in the Stormy Night and City Traffic soundscapes, which disrupts the ambiance.

Users criticized the Product Hunt launch for lacking Google Calendar integration, a crucial missing feature. There were concerns about the application's RAM usage and its potential impact on performance. Additionally, users found the pause/silence functionality disruptive to the continuity and overall ambiance of the effects.


Avatar
85
5
40.0%
5
85
40.0%
Relevance

Lofi. - Lofi music and time-tracking

08 Feb 2023 Productivity

Lofi. (Lofi Dot) is a good design iOS app, with following: - Dot matrix style font UI. - Local Play. - Chill and Focus different states Label. - Time tracking - Widgets, Lock Screen Widgets

Users generally praise the app's easy interface, clean layout, cool animations, and attractive UI, with some discovering it via AppRaven. The app is seen as useful for relaxation, and users congratulate the launch. There's a request for integrations and hope for a Google Play Store release for Android users. One user questions the independence of the UI design.

Users are requesting an Android/Google Play Store version of the product. This appears to be the main criticism.


Avatar
122
7
28.6%
7
122
28.6%
Relevance

lofi.life - Relax & code with ambient sounds, a timer & to-do list

Immerse yourself in tranquil background sounds & stay focused with the help of an integrated Pomodoro timer & convenient to-do list. Say goodbye to scattered thoughts & hello to a more relaxed & efficient coding experience.

Users are overwhelmingly positive about the product's launch, UI, calming sounds, and productivity features like the notepad and Pomodoro timer. Many congratulate the team and express excitement about using the tool. The minimalistic design and dark mode are also appreciated. Some users have requested additional features such as more sound options (including classical music), volume control, the ability to play multiple tracks, saving preferences, and improvements to the Pomodoro timer's music control. One user replaced Lofi Girl with it.

Users expressed concerns about the product's limited variety of sounds and features, with specific requests for more sounds, including classical music ambience. There were suggestions to save preferences and todos to prevent data loss. Some users pointed out issues with the Pomodoro timer not stopping the music and requested that the music should start at 50% volume. A few users also inquired about open-sourcing the project and mentioned challenges with music discovery on existing platforms.


Avatar
186
25
44.0%
25
186
44.0%
Relevance

I quit my job to build a productivity companion app

03 Dec 2024 Productivity

Hi Hacker News,I quit my job three months back and I've been working on an app called Hootz since thenHootz acts like a supportive friend that guides you to stay focused and productive. Below are the key features I've built so far.Focus Sessions: It prompts you to start focus sessions whenever possible. During these sessions, you can select from various music options to maintain your concentration.Automatic Distraction Alert: Hootz automatically identifies when you are distracted during focus sessions, and nudges you to get back to work.Calendar Sync: Syncs with your calendar to help you compare what you planned with what you accomplished.Daily Overview: Provides a clear summary of your day with details on productive time and downtime.Productivity Goals: Helps you set and track your productivity goals.Focus Insights: Identifies the times of day you are most focused and what is causing distractions.I'd really appreciate your feedback!

Asks if it's web-tech or native.


Avatar
1
1
1
1
Relevance

My Simple Lofi Player

01 Nov 2024 Developer Tools

As AI takes over our jobs, we can focus on the important stuff like building our own Lofi players.I added some neat features like sound effects - rain, cafe ambience, people talking, and keyboard typing - that you can play with and customize your lofi experience.Always wanted to have my own little lofi player and I'm going to have some great coding sessions with this hopefully.Appreciate any feedback!


Avatar
2
2
Relevance

Pomodoro Web Application - Boost your productivity with our Pomodoro web app

Our app is based on the Pomodoro technique, a proven method for improving focus, boosting creativity, and getting more done in less time. Whether you're working on a project or studying for an exam, music can help you relax and stay focused.

Users express excitement and congratulations on the launch, praising the focused environment and productivity-enhancing features of the website and application. Many are eager to try it, with one highlighting its potential to eliminate excuses for not working. The calming nature of the application is noted, and there's a specific request for smooth background music options. Several users recommended the tool.


Avatar
95
7
71.4%
7
95
71.4%
Relevance

FocusFusion - Take charge of your productivity

FocusFusion is your personal productivity app, designed exclusively for macOS. It empowers you to take charge of your workday, fostering improved habits through incentivizing sharper focus and heightened efficiency.

FocusFusion's Product Hunt launch received overwhelmingly positive feedback, with many users congratulating the team and praising the app's design, productivity focus, and cross-device syncing. Users found the app helpful for time tracking, staying focused, and boosting productivity, especially for remote workers and those with attention deficits. The clean interface and well-thought-out features were also highlighted. Some users inquired about integrations with tools like Asana and Trello, active focus features, future update roadmaps, and device tracking limits. Overall, FocusFusion is seen as a promising game-changer for desktop productivity on macOS, though one GNOME user was unable to use it.

Users expressed concerns about the app's usability and compatibility, specifically mentioning difficulties with the existing app and incompatibility with GNOME. There were also questions regarding the app's long-term effectiveness in maintaining motivation and habits, as well as requests for integration with existing productivity tools for a consolidated view and for more features beyond site limiting. Finally, a user reported that the video wasn't playing and another requested the ability to hide the app icon in the Dock.


Avatar
318
94
23.4%
94
318
24.5%
Relevance

An app to help you stay Focused

29 Jul 2023 Education Productivity

I built this app in less than 4 hours over a busy and noisy weekend to help me stay focused while studying, during my college days. Since then I have been maintaining this open source project. Its been quite a fruitful and enjoyable ride. Hope you all like it :)

Looks great, consider making it a PWA.

Make it a PWA.


Avatar
5
1
100.0%
1
5
100.0%
Top
OSZAR »