Should I Build It Should I Build It
24 May 2025
Education

A memory aid for young people to help them recall what happened in ...

...their day

Confidence
Engagement
Net use signal
Net buy signal

Idea type: Swamp

The market has seen several mediocre solutions that nobody loves. Unless you can offer something fundamentally different, you’ll likely struggle to stand out or make money.

Should You Build It?

Don't build it.

Your are here

Your idea for a memory aid for young people falls into a crowded space. The 'Swamp' category indicates that many similar solutions exist, but none have truly resonated with users. With 15 similar products already out there, competition is considerable. Engagement, based on the average number of comments on similar products, is low. While we don't have specific use or buy signals for similar products, the sheer number of competitors suggests that differentiation is key. To break through, your product needs a unique angle or approach that addresses the shortcomings of existing memory aids.

Recommendations

  1. Given the crowded market, your first step should be thorough market research. Understand why existing memory aids haven't fully satisfied users. What are their pain points, and what features are missing? Analyze the reviews and feedback of competitor products. Several similar products were criticized by users for their unclear purpose, so you'll need to clearly define your product's use cases.
  2. Consider niching down and focusing on a specific group of young people. For example, you could tailor your memory aid to students preparing for exams, young professionals networking at events, or individuals with specific memory challenges. A more focused approach will allow you to create a more relevant and valuable product.
  3. Explore partnerships with educational institutions, youth organizations, or memory-related support groups. Collaborating with established entities can provide access to a target audience, credibility, and valuable feedback on your product.
  4. Instead of directly competing with existing apps, explore building tools or features that enhance them. This could involve creating integrations with popular calendar apps, note-taking platforms, or social media channels. Consider providing integrations, plugins or extensions for existing providers. This strategy allows you to tap into an established user base and reduce the risk of direct competition.
  5. Pay close attention to the user experience. The comments from similar products highlight the importance of simplicity, clean design, and ease of use. Make sure your app is intuitive and enjoyable to use. Some users in the similar products discussion requested an Android version of the app, so you may want to expand into multiple platforms.
  6. Incorporate features that are missing from existing solutions. Some users suggested features like video support, cross-device sync, tagging, rich media support, and collaboration features. Implementing a free trial could address some users' concerns about up-front payments.
  7. Before investing heavily in development, validate your idea with potential users. Create a prototype or MVP and gather feedback on its usability, features, and value proposition. Iterate based on user feedback to ensure your product meets their needs.
  8. Carefully consider your business model. Will you offer a free version with limited features, a subscription-based service, or a one-time purchase? Ensure your pricing is competitive and aligns with the value you provide.
  9. Don't be afraid to pivot or adjust your idea based on market feedback. The 'Swamp' category suggests that you may need to adapt your approach to find a winning formula. Stay open to new opportunities and be willing to iterate your product until it resonates with users.

Questions

  1. What specific problem are you solving for young people that existing memory aids don't address adequately?
  2. How will you differentiate your memory aid from the many similar products already available in the market?
  3. What monetization strategy will you use to ensure the long-term sustainability of your product, and how will you validate this strategy early on?

Your are here

Your idea for a memory aid for young people falls into a crowded space. The 'Swamp' category indicates that many similar solutions exist, but none have truly resonated with users. With 15 similar products already out there, competition is considerable. Engagement, based on the average number of comments on similar products, is low. While we don't have specific use or buy signals for similar products, the sheer number of competitors suggests that differentiation is key. To break through, your product needs a unique angle or approach that addresses the shortcomings of existing memory aids.

Recommendations

  1. Given the crowded market, your first step should be thorough market research. Understand why existing memory aids haven't fully satisfied users. What are their pain points, and what features are missing? Analyze the reviews and feedback of competitor products. Several similar products were criticized by users for their unclear purpose, so you'll need to clearly define your product's use cases.
  2. Consider niching down and focusing on a specific group of young people. For example, you could tailor your memory aid to students preparing for exams, young professionals networking at events, or individuals with specific memory challenges. A more focused approach will allow you to create a more relevant and valuable product.
  3. Explore partnerships with educational institutions, youth organizations, or memory-related support groups. Collaborating with established entities can provide access to a target audience, credibility, and valuable feedback on your product.
  4. Instead of directly competing with existing apps, explore building tools or features that enhance them. This could involve creating integrations with popular calendar apps, note-taking platforms, or social media channels. Consider providing integrations, plugins or extensions for existing providers. This strategy allows you to tap into an established user base and reduce the risk of direct competition.
  5. Pay close attention to the user experience. The comments from similar products highlight the importance of simplicity, clean design, and ease of use. Make sure your app is intuitive and enjoyable to use. Some users in the similar products discussion requested an Android version of the app, so you may want to expand into multiple platforms.
  6. Incorporate features that are missing from existing solutions. Some users suggested features like video support, cross-device sync, tagging, rich media support, and collaboration features. Implementing a free trial could address some users' concerns about up-front payments.
  7. Before investing heavily in development, validate your idea with potential users. Create a prototype or MVP and gather feedback on its usability, features, and value proposition. Iterate based on user feedback to ensure your product meets their needs.
  8. Carefully consider your business model. Will you offer a free version with limited features, a subscription-based service, or a one-time purchase? Ensure your pricing is competitive and aligns with the value you provide.
  9. Don't be afraid to pivot or adjust your idea based on market feedback. The 'Swamp' category suggests that you may need to adapt your approach to find a winning formula. Stay open to new opportunities and be willing to iterate your product until it resonates with users.

Questions

  1. What specific problem are you solving for young people that existing memory aids don't address adequately?
  2. How will you differentiate your memory aid from the many similar products already available in the market?
  3. What monetization strategy will you use to ensure the long-term sustainability of your product, and how will you validate this strategy early on?

  • Confidence: High
    • Number of similar products: 15
  • Engagement: Low
    • Average number of comments: 3
  • Net use signal: 19.8%
    • Positive use signal: 19.8%
    • Negative use signal: 0.0%
  • Net buy signal: 1.7%
    • Positive buy signal: 1.7%
    • Negative buy signal: 0.0%

This chart summarizes all the similar products we found for your idea in a single plot.

The x-axis represents the overall feedback each product received. This is calculated from the net use and buy signals that were expressed in the comments. The maximum is +1, which means all comments (across all similar products) were positive, expressed a willingness to use & buy said product. The minimum is -1 and it means the exact opposite.

The y-axis captures the strength of the signal, i.e. how many people commented and how does this rank against other products in this category. The maximum is +1, which means these products were the most liked, upvoted and talked about launches recently. The minimum is 0, meaning zero engagement or feedback was received.

The sizes of the product dots are determined by the relevance to your idea, where 10 is the maximum.

Your idea is the big blueish dot, which should lie somewhere in the polygon defined by these products. It can be off-center because we use custom weighting to summarize these metrics.

Similar products

Relevance

Remi, the easiest way to remember every day (A journaling tool I made)

10 Apr 2024 Lifestyle

Hello HN! My name is Brice. Remi Journal is a project I've been working on with my sister to make it easier to remember thoughts, memories, and little moments from every day. It also helps you stay on top of habits, track personal stats, and stores images to go with your journal pages.I made Remi since I've always wanted to look back on old memories, but I'm too lazy to sit down and write a journal for a half hour each night. I tried recording voice notes, but they were too disorganized and hard to search.It's still in very early beta, but I was hoping I could get some feedback and check that I'm headed in a good direction.To use Remi, you can fill out the form on the site (it needs to know your phone number to work, but no credit card info necessary). Afterwards, you can add Remi as a contact on WhatsApp. You can then send Remi voice memos at various times of day to journal - feel free to ramble, since Remi will handle the organization for you.Remi will ask questions to guide you through different reflections and gather stats to get a full picture of your day so that it can create a journal entry. You can also send up to four photos to store with the daily entry.Each night at 4am, Remi will generate a journal page for you based on what you said in the conversation. You can view your page through your dashboard and make any edits or revisions you'd like. It will try to highlight any potentially misheard words or phrases to make revising easier.By the way, all of your data on the database side is encrypted and not human readable. I have been working hard to make it as secure as possible since I have lots of my own private thoughts and memories in there.I think that's about it. If any of you are interested in this sort of thing, I'd really appreciate it if you could try it out and let me know your thoughts! Thanks so much in advance!

Avatar
1
1
Relevance

Memory - Your private daily photo journal for iPhone

21 Dec 2024 iOS Photography Lifestyle

Memory is the simplest way to document your story. Memory helps you capture memories from your day with daily reminders. With a focus on simplicity, minimalism, and privacy, Memory builds a personal photo diary that's yours to cherish forever.

Users praise the app's simple and clean design, highlighting its minimalist approach to photo journaling and capturing meaningful moments. The app is described as thoughtful, private, and self-explanatory. Several users congratulated the launch. A few comments mentioned wanting video support, and one user reported that the app opens the gallery instead of the camera for the first capture. Overall, the app's focus on simplicity and ease of use resonates positively.

Users questioned the product's differentiation from existing solutions like Day One and expressed interest in platform expansion. A specific suggestion was made to improve the initial user experience by opening the camera directly instead of the gallery for the first capture.

Avatar
322
8
12.5%
8
322
12.5%
Relevance

Dear Little One - Your child's story, narrated by you

30 Jan 2024 Parenting Family Photo & Video

Easier and more meaningful than a baby book. Capture memories with quick video messages for your child to relive one day.

The product launch is receiving positive feedback, with users calling it a beautiful and heartwarming idea. Suggestions include integrating with iPhone photos, identifying kids, recommending daily memories, and using 'child's name' instead of 'baby name'. Some users are trying the product and find it interesting. There's also a question about the creator's motivation. A user noted that baby books are magical because they are tangible, not digital, suggesting a preference for physical over digital formats.

The primary criticisms are the lack of a free trial or testing period, as payment is required upfront. Additionally, users desire the option to print albums directly from the platform.

Avatar
89
8
37.5%
8
89
37.5%
Relevance

NoteIt - Easy notes & memos

06 Aug 2023 Notes Writing Calendar

Capture ideas, memories and inspirations at anytime, anywhere.

Users praise the app's simplicity and clean interface for forming a daily writing habit. Many are excited to use the product for idea organization. Key requests include Android availability, cross-device sync, tagging, rich media support, collaboration features, and improved search. Users inquire about the product link and congratulate the launch. Gratitude is expressed for a long-awaited solution. Some users are specifically waiting for an Android version before adopting the app.

Users are requesting additional features to improve the user experience. A significant criticism is the lack of an Android version, with many users awaiting its release. Additionally, there's a demand for a web or desktop application to facilitate usage in office environments.

Avatar
87
12
41.7%
8.3%
12
87
41.7%
8.3%
Relevance

Flashbak - Wondering what you were doing on this day in past years?

07 Jun 2024 Social Media Social Networking Tech

Flashbak lets you relive memories by posting photos from the same date in past years. Connect with friends, explore their flashbaks, and keep a digital journal of your life's moments. Join 80,000+ users on a nostalgic journey. Download now!

The Product Hunt launch received congratulations and sparked curiosity about aiding users with photo gaps. Users found it useful for marketers, photographers, and bloggers, though self-review was noted as difficult. A question was raised regarding the presence of the Plex logo.

Users questioned how the application addresses gaps in photo history and raised concerns about the presence of the Plex logo within the app.

Avatar
79
3
3
79
Relevance

Recall Memory – Your Personal Local Time Machine for Mac

21 May 2024 Productivity

Recall Memory is a free Sandboxed Mac App which let's you scroll through time and allows you to "Recall" what you were doing earlier.Recall works by capturing the active window every second and only saves screenshots with significant changes. Making it easy to scroll through what you were doing earlier.All data is processed and always stored locally.

Users find the product interesting but are unsure of its necessity and are asking for future use cases. One user mentions that Sun Solaris had a similar ZFS snapshot feature in 2012. Another user points out the absence of a 'Start' button in the Recall menu. Additionally, a user mentions forgetting the menu bar but expresses willingness to try it out.

Users criticized the tool for its unclear purpose, lack of a 'Start' button, and a forgettable menu bar.

Avatar
8
4
25.0%
4
8
25.0%
Relevance

Recall – An App to Save Your Internet Artifacts

09 Jan 2024 Productivity

Hi everyone! I often find myself having to save YouTube videos, shorts, Threads etc. I want to revisit later on separate sites or having to message myself links to check out later.To solve this, I started building an app called Recall. Feel free to try it out and provide any feedback that you might have. It's still in active development and I will try to incorporate any suggestions that I feel will make it better.

Avatar
1
1
Relevance

Postgram - Memories should be experienced where they were made.

29 Aug 2024 Social Media Photography

With Postgram, you share moments with friends through photos and notes that they can only unlock once they’re physically present at the location.

Postgram's launch on Product Hunt has generated excitement, with users eager to try it out. There's anticipation for future updates. Users express interest in the core concept of placing memories in their original locations, and they congratulate Christian on the launch's success.

Avatar
6
5
40.0%
5
6
40.0%
Top
OSZAR »